--"Too Little Too Late", JojoI was watching
The Class, which is turning into one of my favorite new shows, last night and was startled to discover a very poignant scene amidst the hilarity. I'm not comparing it by any means to the great emotional heart-tuggers like
Avonlea or
Everwood, but as I sat watching Duncan make her confession to Nicole about why he dumped her ten years ago suddenly, I was actually moved to, well, write a post about it. All season it had been overtly mentioned that Duncan regretted losing the love of his life all those many years ago and called it the biggest mistake he ever made. Conversely, Nicole, continually found herself being torn between Duncan, the first love of her life, and Yonk, the man she eventually married. All season it was this big secret what broke them up in the first place, but I had the sense that it was something trivial and that the two of them truly were a case of bad timing and bad judgment. However, believing one thing and hearing it out loud are two quite different experiences.
Basically, last night Duncan admitted that the reason he broke up with her in high school was that she "was acting somewhat like a bitch" and that he just snapped. He tried to call her the next morning to patch things up, but her mom answered, and he was too embarrassed to call back for the next few days. He then went on to explain that a week after that he heard through the high school grapevine that she was already going out with this other guy and that was that. It was only later he found out she'd gone out with the new guy one time and that she had been secretly hoping the two of them would get back together eventually. Seeing his face when she told him, "it was just the one time," and him answering, "somebody eventually told me a year later, but by then it was too late," was heartbreaking. Compile that with seeing her confusion at his big revelation about why he did it:
"So it wasn't because I was a bitch all the time?"
"Nope."
"And I was only somewhat being a bitch that night. Not a raging bitch, but somewhat?"
"Yes."
"And here I thought it was this huge reason about why you didn't like me or why you thought we weren't meant for each other."
It literally tore me up inside because that sense of regret and emotional imprisonment is the stuff that truly gets to me. People always expect melodrama to arise out of illness or death, but I think the truly saddening experiences are the ones born out of being separated from somebody you were never meant to be separated from due to stupidity, dumb bad luck, or true misfortune. I don't care what anybody says, nothing hurts more knowing you could have been together with someone and you blew it.
Most of the time, I'm on the front of end of regretting a choice a made or a decision I came to. Most of the time I'm the one who is looking back on my life and trying to pinpoint where I went wrong.
There was one time, though, where I actually saw what it was like to be on the other end of someone's regret.
----
It was right after I had met DeAnn in July of '98 which would place the time at August, I think. I think the two of us had been going out for a month or so. Everything had been proceeding smoothly so with her so, of course, out of the blue I get a call from the ex who came before her, Miss Tara. I don't know if I've ever gone into detail just how bad my break-up with her had been, but I'm fairly sure I had. To borrow a device from Nabokov, it was bad (tears, four days). Not only had it happened on a four-day trip to visit her in Maryland, but the following eighteen months of trying to be friends with her proved to be excruciatingly bad. The whole experiment of whether or not the two of us could remain friends culminated in my being stood-up in Philadelphia in May of '98 after it had already been agreed that the main reason I was flying there at all was to see her. After that, both of us pretty much knew there was nothing left to salvage. I think we stopped talking right at the beginning of June of that year.
Yes, it came as quite a shock when I heard Tara's voice on the other end of the line asking me how I was doing and what I'd been up to. I've met a lot of women. I've dated a couple. Even after collecting such a large sample, I still maintain that Tara had the most melodious voice I have ever heard. There was nothing specific about it, but if could imagine what a woman's voice is supposed to sound like if you were picturing the most feminine and alluring voice possible it would be hers. It wasn't sexy or persuasive. It was just nice. Smooth. Soothing. And when she trained her voice to sing, that quality of perfection ramped up considerably. She was always the best singer of anybody I have ever known.
I just remember before I'd met DeAnn how broken I was and how I kept wishing, hope against hope, that Tara and I would get back together someday eventually. It's probably how everyone feels when that happens to them. But, for whatever reason, one always thinks one is the first person to ever feel heartache or loss. For whatever reason, one always believes no one else has ever felt the pain like we've felt. One always thinks one's case is different. But it isn't. I'm not going to say it was the heart rending loss that destroyed me for life because it wasn't. At most, it screwed up my last year at USC and perhaps contributed my not wanting to jumping head-first into the job market. A job? How could anyone expect me to look for a job when my heart was torn into a million flamable pieces? Like everyone else will tell you at the time it happens to them, to me it hurt like no other hurt and I didn't see any way past it.
However, by the time she called that August, I had literally forgotten how much it hurt. She asked me if I was still distressed. Distressed? Not really. She asked me if I ever thought about her still even after not talking for two months. I told her, yeah, of course I still thought about her. She was a large part of my life for a long time. But how I thought about her had changed. It's one thing to be alone and miserable, pining for the one that got away. It's another to have somebody new in your life who isn't better or worse than your last girlfriend, just different. At that time, with my relationship with DeAnn being so new and all, different was good. Different meant I didn't have to worry about what Tara's high school friends thought of me because DeAnn was older than Tara had been when we had first started going out. Different meant I didn't have to contend with Tara's very proper and strict parents. Different meant I didn't have to be fumbling around with someone who was so unsure of herself. DeAnn may have her faults, but she'll never let you know she gets flustered. Her reaction to being confused was to take charge of the situation despite not always having the best solution. At the time, that's what I needed.
Eventually the conversation with Tara turned to the matter of her coming to visit California again in two weeks' time. She wanted to know if we could meet up again. At first, I was torn as to whether I should see her for old time's sake or if I should allow whatever we had between us die. I was very close to saying it was a good idea to meet up when I heard it. The way her voice sounded wasn't merely the pleasant tones I'd been accustomed to from her. Her voice also carried something that reminded me of somebody else.
Namely, it reminded me of me when I had been so anxious to see her again in Philadelphia. It reminded me of the person when I was still waiting around for her. It wasn't desperation per se, but she definitely sounded like a person who was still holding the door open for me to come back through.
The only thing was I'd already shut that door two months' prior.
That's when I told her about DeAnn and how happy she made me. Tara tried to be a good sport about it, but there was a definite tinge of disappointment in her voice. I don't think she ever fully expected me to meet someone else. To her I'd always been somebody who could serve as a back-up plan. I attempted to do my best to let her know that I no longer harbored any ill will towards her, but it was probably for the best we stopped speaking. I didn't want to lead her on into think something could be salvaged should DeAnn and I wither later on down the line. Tara was a sweet girl and there was a time I loved her to bits and pieces, but she had had her opportunity and being with her had ceased being a goal of mine. Whether or not my new relationship with DeAnn managed to last, I knew, I finally knew that Tara would never be it again.
I think like
The Class there are some people who you'll always be close with, no matter how long the two of you are apart. That's like me and B. But there are other people who you can come to be attached to for a time, but once it's over, it's over. With those people you can't linger onto the hope that you can keep on reliving the happy memories you shared once. With those people it isn't possible to go back to.
With those people, you end up adopting the attitude that Duncan and Nicole share (for now). You have your one chance and you just have to make it count, otherwise, you could end up regretting it ten years down the line and allow it to eat you alive.
I don't know if Tara still feels it to this day, but I knew she felt it by the end of the conversation. And, yes, I do believe we ended the conversation by stating that we loved each other, but it was more like the pronouncment of affection you give to an old friend who is moving away for good to Stockholm. It was good to say, but it only held that quality because I knew it would be the last time I'd ever to say it to her.
There would be no second chances for us.
I remember the first thing I did after getting off the phone with her was to call DeAnn at home. I needed to be reminded of what I had gained at that point because what I'd lost just didn't seem to matter any more.
Yours Swimmingly,
mojo shivers
Labels: honesty, reconciling, regret, second chances